Lisa O from
East Setauket, NY on Oct 1, 2012
My husband had his bachelors party here. While I wasn't there, he and his buds came home and said they had a wonderful time. Good food and fun. Of course I know they went to other places too, but at least they started out on a good course.
Bonnie E Wallace from
Smithtown, NY on Sep 22, 2012
Being a newcomer here, I went out looking for a snazzy bar and fine dining jaunt and I was advised by a few of my neighbors to head to O’s Food and Wine Bar. I went and hoped for a wonderful experience and was devastated at what I saw.
The place was decent but certainly not suave enough for a New Yorker like me, who’s used to high town dining. Okay, the music scene is terribly lacking and I was served warm beer, burnt fish fry (with an apology) and terrible dessert.
People say I’ve had a bad day there, and they’ve never heard anything short of perfect service from the place. So, I guess I’ll head there again. Recommend? – Umm. I don’t know – I’ll keep you people updated for when I visit there next.
HT from
Kings Park, NY on Aug 23, 2012
I came in here years ago when it was Oscar's, and again when it was being refurbished. During the refurbishing I remember some issues, like the fact that they had no red wine, and it seemed like their dishes were more ambitious than their cooks, if that makes sense.
Returning about a year later, I was pleasantly surprised with the strides ahead they'd made. The bar remains a great place to hang out with a friendly bartender (Jenn), and a good crowd, and the restaurant is also great for a sit-down meal. Tapas are delicious, especially the calamari with the BBQ sauce. I'm picky about calamari, and they were well cooked, not too chewy. I'm not a fan of their salmon however; it is a bit fishy for me, and some of their dishes can still be a tad on the salty side. Dessert here is also rather good, had the molten chocolate cake and it was extra rich and delicious. The homemade ice cream was also awesome.
Share Your Review
Report incorrect info
