Our business hours are open 7 days a week. Accepted forms of payment are american express, mastercard and visa.

View Large Map    Get Directions

Teresa Farmer from Centereach, NY on Jan 16, 2015
I have never been to another pizza place that I like as much as this one. It is so seldom in life you find a restaurant which is the best of everything you have tried. The town I lived in before had the best Chinese restaurant, and I haven't found anything like that here. But this is the best pizza restaurant I've ever eaten at, and that makes up for it! Doris Howell from Saint James, NY on Jul 20, 2013
Cataffo's isn't the most creative pizzeria in town, but what they do, they do very well. Their recipes are mostly for very basic, simple traditional types of pies. They are really delicious though, and even though I would prefer more variety, if I want something simple, this is usually the first place I head out to. If I am in the mood for some kind of fancy specialty pizza, I usually go somewhere else. The standout food here is the garlic knots though. They aren't too greasy, but aren't dry either, and they are loaded with flavor! At 25 cents each, they're also a pretty smashing deal. I divide my pizza runs pretty evenly between this place and another, depending on what I'm in the mood for. No complaints could be made about prices either; they're cheap! I generally take out my food, but I eat sometimes on game nights since they usually have sports channel on. Share Your Review

Do you have any experience using Cataffos's Pizza? If so, please rate your experience and let others hear about it using the form below.
 

Your Name:
City, State:	,
My Rating:
My Review:	Do not enter html
	Please enter this code into the box below.
Enter Code: